Market Insights: A Comprehensive Look at Asset Classes as October Comes to a Close

As we approach the end of October, the financial landscape is influenced by various factors, including fluctuating energy prices, geopolitical uncertainties, and a crucial upcoming U.S. presidential election. In this article, we provide insights into how different asset classes are performing in 2023, highlighting the key observations from financial advisors and asset managers.

Energy Sector: A Year of Underperformance

After leading the market in 2022, the energy sector has struggled in 2023, emerging as the worst performer within the S&P 500, despite recording a modest gain of 7.95% year-to-date as of October 25. This downturn is attributed to decreasing prices of crude oil and natural gas.

Ayako Yoshioka, a portfolio consulting director at Wealth Enhancement Group, emphasizes the impact of geopolitical risks and China’s tepid demand for oil. ‘Investors are particularly focused on the timing and recovery pathways for oil demand, especially following recent economic stimulus announcements in China,’ Yoshioka explains. Moreover, the anticipated oversupply of natural gas as new capacity comes online is causing concern among investors.

Growth Stocks: Leading the Pack

In stark contrast to energy stocks, growth stocks have remained a strong contender, leading the broader S&P 500 both year-to-date and over the past three months. These stocks, which typically belong to sectors like technology, consumer discretionary, and health care, are characterized by their potential for swift earnings growth.

According to Jon Burkett-St. Laurent, senior portfolio manager at Exencial Wealth Advisors, ‘U.S. large-cap growth stocks are highly profitable with steady growth.’ However, he warns investors that historical data suggests predicting growth can be challenging, warning of possible valuation risks if the market overestimates the sustainability of high growth rates.

Non-U.S. Developed Markets: A Safe Haven for Investment

Investors seeking stocks with lower valuations relative to U.S. counterparts might explore non-U.S. developed markets, which appear appealing to portfolio managers. Krishna Mohanraj, CFA and portfolio manager at Diamond Hill Capital Management, recommends focusing on Europe, where many fundamentally strong companies are trading at attractive valuations. He notes, ‘Some of these European companies are not reliant on local economic growth, making them suitable for uncertain economic conditions.’

Similarly, Japan presents investment opportunities, particularly due to enhanced shareholder return initiatives.

Emerging Markets: Spotting Opportunities

Turning to emerging markets, the Indian economy stands out, driven by a flourishing business environment that has garnered attention from international investors. Mohanraj highlights the importance of re-evaluating what constitutes an emerging market, suggesting that nations like China, often categorized as emerging, may be better regarded as developed markets.

Burkett-St. Laurent concurs, advocating for some exposure to markets outside of North America, Europe, and Japan.

Defensive Stocks: Stability in Uncertain Times

Defensive stocks, particularly in the utilities, health care, and consumer staples sectors, have demonstrated their resilience even amidst economic uncertainty. As of now, the utilities sector has been a top performer within the S&P 500.

Burkett-St. Laurent comments that the surge in valuations within these defensive sectors stems from heightened uncertainty concerning economic growth and upcoming elections. However, he warns that investors might be overvaluing the perceived safety these stocks offer.

Dividend Stocks: Consistent Returns

Dividend-paying stocks are generally a hallmark of defensive sectors, consistently rewarding investors. The Utilities Select Sector SPDR Fund and Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund offer yields of 2.7% and 2.6%, respectively. Such stable dividend returns have historically contributed significantly to overall portfolio growth.

Despite the reliability of dividends, Burkett-St. Laurent argues against making allocations based solely on dividend yield due to potential inefficiencies in this investment strategy.

Commodities: Mixed Signals Ahead

Many investors are looking at commodities for portfolio diversification. The commodities market has recently exhibited mixed signals, particularly influenced by China’s economic stance. Will Rhind, founder of GraniteShares ETFs, discusses how China’s stimulus packages have sparked hope for price increases in some metals but cautions that copper continues to show volatility due to weak global manufacturing.

Gold, in particular, has gained traction as a safe haven asset amid market volatility, outperforming the S&P 500 significantly. However, concerns linger regarding the potential downside should China slow its gold purchases.

Fixed Income: The Role of Treasuries

The 10-year Treasury has emerged as a reliable safe haven amid uncertainty, currently yielding around 4%. Investors may find these yields attractive, especially compared to the historically low rates seen in the past decade. However, analysts caution that the upcoming election could introduce risks, particularly if proposed tariffs lead to inflation and rising interest rates.

Cryptocurrencies: A Cautious Landscape

Finally, cryptocurrencies maintain a cautious appeal among investors this year, notably Bitcoin, which remains above its 2023 lows, despite trading just below its year-to-date high. The recent introduction of several spot Bitcoin ETFs has garnered significant interest and investments.

Still, many financial experts, including Burkett-St. Laurent, advise caution. He characterizes cryptocurrencies as speculative assets that could amplify existing portfolio risks rather than provide diversification benefits.

Conclusion

As October draws to a close, the intricacies of various asset classes present a mixed but insightful picture for investors navigating a complex financial landscape. With the presidential election approaching and global economic uncertainties persisting, strategizing based on the current trends across these sectors might yield fruitful opportunities in the final months of the year.

Share this article: