Crypto’s Slump: A Cultural Problem as Much as a Financial One
By Allison Morrow
Published: December 18, 2025
Updated: December 18, 2025, 5:31 AM ET
New York — The cryptocurrency market is experiencing one of its toughest years yet, marking a slump that appears to be influenced as much by cultural issues as by financial factors.
Bitcoin, the bellwether of the crypto world, had a strong start to the year, peaking at about $126,000 in October—a more than 30% gain since January. However, since that peak, bitcoin has lost all of those gains and dipped below its January price, down roughly 7% for the year. This performance significantly trails the S&P 500 index, which has risen approximately 15% over the same period.
Regulatory and institutional landscapes have shifted favorably toward crypto. The stringent Biden-era regulations that once hindered crypto expansion in the United States have been replaced by a pro-crypto administration, sometimes dubbed the "crypto president." Congress is actively moving forward with legislation supported by the industry, and institutional adoption has been robust, including billions funneled through bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs).
Despite these gains, bitcoin and the broader crypto market have struggled to maintain momentum, recently falling from about $90,000 to near $86,000 following another sharp selloff.
Technical issues such as an excessive buildup of highly leveraged speculative positions contributed to an early October flash crash and subsequent selloffs. However, the extended downturn doesn’t appear to be solely a hangover from these events.
Interestingly, appetite for risk has remained strong in other sectors—most notably, the technology-heavy Nasdaq index has outperformed even the broader stock market. The question arises: why are investors increasingly wary of crypto risk?
Industry observers point to the culture surrounding crypto as a key deterrent keeping investors hesitant. Although the legal and regulatory environment has improved markedly, the community still struggles to manage a portion of its user base that engages in scams, disruptive antics, and criminal behavior, which undermine broader trust.
For instance, during the summer, memecoin promoters orchestrated antics such as throwing sex toys onto the court during WNBA games in an attempt to "make memes funny again." Crypto ATM scams have surged, costing Americans more than $330 million in losses this year. Even more alarmingly, kidnappers have targeted crypto investors to force the transfer of digital wallet passwords in so-called "wrench attacks"—with more than 30 reported incidents in 2025 alone.
One high-profile case this summer involved a 28-year-old crypto investor who escaped captivity in a luxury Manhattan apartment after being held against his will and threatened with death by assailants demanding access to his crypto assets.
These episodes, coupled with the inherent volatility of crypto markets, understandably spook many potential and current investors. Cornell University economist Eswar Prasad highlighted this tension, noting that retail investors oscillate between fear of missing out on potential gains and concerns about the dubious elements within the crypto ecosystem.
“The volatility we see is amplified by retail investors who are attracted to the potential upside but are quick to exit when fears about crypto’s unsavory aspects resurface,” Prasad explained.
Bitcoin’s rally earlier in the year, which coincided with the re-election of President Donald Trump—an outspoken crypto advocate—drew new investors who focused primarily on price appreciation rather than cultural or political considerations. Yet, once prices started declining, there was little to encourage these investors to stay.
“They’re eager to dip their toes in the water,” Prasad said, “but just as ready to pull back when the conditions look uncertain. The underlying concerns about crypto’s culture are now resurfacing.”
While crypto investing itself isn’t inherently flawed, the community’s cultural and reputational challenges continue to limit mainstream confidence and broader adoption. As the market navigates these complexities, industry leaders face the ongoing task of balancing innovation with the need for safeguards that address these cultural obstacles.
For those who invested near bitcoin’s peak earlier this year, the current market dip only deepens the sense of uncertainty. Whether the industry can mature culturally alongside its technical development may prove pivotal for crypto’s long-term viability.
This article originally appeared in CNN Business’ Nightcap newsletter. To receive it in your inbox, sign up for free at CNN Business.