Weekend Money: ‘Unacceptable’ – Expert Tips on Complaining in Restaurants

Advice from Elite Chefs and a Royal Butler on Dining Etiquette

As the cost of living continues to impact household budgets, many Britons are opting to dine out less frequently yet with higher expectations when they do. With this increased scrutiny, knowing how to address potential grievances in restaurants can be crucial. According to insights from top chefs, an etiquette expert, and Grant Harold, a former butler to the King, British diners could use a lesson in effective complaint strategies without offending staff or damaging their dining experience.

Understanding the British Diner’s Dilemma

Brian Mcelderry, an esteemed chef with nearly 50 years in the culinary world, believes that British diners tend to shy away from voicing complaints. "The UK is notoriously bad at complaining," he remarked, highlighting how this cultural hesitation can lead to unsatisfactory dining experiences. In contrast, diners from the United States are encouraged to express their concerns openly, whereas in France, diners tend to have a more nuanced understanding of culinary standards.

"They know how to complain but don’t do so frivolously,” said Mcelderry, noting that the most common dish that diners mistakenly complain about is steak. His advice? "If you don’t want fat, don’t order ribeye. If you want it well done, expect a 15-minute wait."

The Importance of Attitude

When a complaint is warranted, how it’s presented can significantly influence the response from the restaurant staff. Jesse Dunford Wood, a chef patron at London’s Parlour, shared a particularly alarming incident involving a tooth found in a dish. His experience reinforces the notion that politeness and calmness can lead to better resolution outcomes.

Laura Windsor, head of the Etiquette Academy, suggests handling complaints with patience and direct communication. “Shouting while complaining makes one look ridiculous and arrogant,” she explains. Instead, she encourages discreet discussions with the staff away from the rest of the patrons.

Mcelderry echoed this sentiment by stating that polite customers are often rewarded with complimentary items or services. "Absolutely, 2,000%. It’s the answer to everything,” he asserted.

Knowing When to Complain

Experts agree that addressing issues promptly is crucial. Grant Harold, who runs the Royal School of Etiquette, states that it is "completely unacceptable" to eat more than a few mouthfuls before complaining, especially about a significant issue. He also emphasized that raising concerns after consuming an entire meal with the expectation of a free dish is "taking the piss."

In hospitality, there’s a general understanding that subtle complaints may arise after consuming a dish, but dining out drunk or having a full table can complicate such discussions. Daniel Thompson, general manager at the Thurlestone Hotel in Devon, remarked, "If you get three-quarters of the way through your meal and then decide your chicken is undercooked, it is quite unacceptable."

Appropriate Waiting Times

When it comes to waiting for food, patience is key. Wood suggests diners should not get irate within the first 10 minutes, as a three-course meal should ideally last about 90 minutes. If diners wait longer than anticipated, they may justifiably expect a discount or a complimentary drink.

Harold pointed out that a free bottle of wine is often the standard compensation for significant delays, while suggesting that a full meal should only be considered free in instances of severe mishaps.

Gratuity and Service Expectations

Lastly, regarding gratuity, Mcelderry noted that British diners need to be proactive about their service expectations. If the service falls short, he encourages customers to communicate this to the waiter and consider revoking any automatic tips reflected in the bill. Windsor supports this by stressing that tipping is meant to reflect one’s appreciation, and poor service should be addressed appropriately.

Conclusion

Dining out should be an enjoyable experience, even amid potential hiccups. The advice provided by chefs and etiquette experts serves as a guide for diners to express their concerns effectively and respectfully, ensuring they can make the most of their restaurant visits without compromising on standards or etiquette. As these experts illustrate, a well-timed complaint, paired with the right attitude, can lead to a successful resolution where both diners and restaurants can come away satisfied.

Share this article: