Crypto ETFs: A Shift Towards Centralization in a Decentralized World

By Agne Linge, Head of Growth at WeFi
June 9, 2025

In recent months, cryptocurrency exchange-traded funds (ETFs) have garnered significant attention, attracting billions in inflows and positioning themselves as a legitimate asset class in the eyes of mainstream investors. While many hail this development as a victory for the cryptocurrency industry, a closer examination reveals that these financial instruments undermine the very principles that define the realm of cryptocurrencies: decentralization, self-custody, and financial empowerment.

The Rise of Crypto ETFs

Since the regulatory drama that unfolded in January, more than $40 billion has flowed into spot Bitcoin ETFs in the United States alone. For advocates, this influx signifies an essential breakthrough, suggesting a growing interest in cryptocurrencies among investors who once hesitated due to regulatory ambiguities and technological complexities. Crypto ETFs are designed to simplify the process of investing in digital assets, providing a familiar avenue for diversification through traditional brokerage accounts rather than requiring investors to manage actual cryptocurrency holdings.

The mainstream appeal of crypto ETFs is underscored by the increased investor confidence attributed to their regulatory oversight. Many view these funds as a gateway to the digital asset world, offering a sense of security and alignment with traditional financial norms. However, the rise of these funds raises critical concerns regarding their impact on the core ethos of the cryptocurrency movement.

The Underlying Issues with ETFs

While crypto ETFs promise greater accessibility, it is essential to recognize the divergence from traditional cryptocurrency values. For instance, the design of these funds can significantly differ depending on jurisdiction. In Hong Kong, for example, the in-kind ETF model requires actual crypto backing for each fund share, allowing investors to exchange shares for the underlying assets. Contrastingly, the cash-based model favored in the United States involves converting ETF shares via U.S. dollars, distancing the investment from the cryptocurrency itself and adding a layer of fiat currency influence.

This reliance on fiat currency not only enhances regulatory scrutiny aimed at preventing market manipulation but may also obscure the inherent value of cryptocurrencies. The fundamental challenge remains that while ETFs provide market exposure, they strip away true ownership. Investors are left with custodial risks and management fees, reminiscent of traditional financial systems—precisely what decentralized finance (DeFi) sought to avoid.

The Implications of Centralization

Spot ETFs represent not only a shift in the way cryptocurrencies are accessed but may also threaten the decentralized nature of many digital assets. Major financial institutions, such as BlackRock, are amassing substantial holdings in Bitcoin and ether, potentially stifling the growth of smaller crypto asset managers and creating monopolistic choke points within the ecosystems they control.

Moreover, investors holding ETF shares lack the ability to engage in governance, yield farming, or utilize income-generating DeFi opportunities. This absence of direct participation diminishes the empowering aspects of DeFi, which are based on self-custody and autonomy—a stark contrast to the traditional finance approach that ETFs mimic.

A Call to Revisit Crypto Values

Despite the apparent conveniences and greater oversight that crypto ETFs offer, they represent a significant departure from the original goals of the cryptocurrency movement. The foundational ethos of decentralization emphasizes individual control over assets, thereby fostering innovation and community engagement. By prioritizing institutional involvement and passive investment strategies, crypto ETFs risk relegating the very principles that positioned cryptocurrencies as revolutionary financial instruments to the sidelines.

In summary, while crypto ETFs may provide a sense of safety and simplicity, they may ultimately detract from the financial independence and empowerment that define the spirit of cryptocurrencies. As the industry continues to evolve, it is crucial to remember the essence of decentralization and the importance of direct ownership in preserving the innovation and growth potential inherent within the crypto ecosystem.

This article is for general information purposes and should not be construed as legal or investment advice. The views expressed herein are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Cointelegraph.

Share this article: