SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce Compares U.S. Crypto Regulations to Playing ‘The Floor is Lava’ in the Dark
April 25, 2023 — The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) approach to cryptocurrency regulations is in dire need of clarity, according to Commissioner Hester Peirce, who likened navigating the current landscape to playing the childhood game “the floor is lava” without any light. This statement was made at the SEC’s “Know Your Custodian” roundtable event earlier this week.
Navigating the Regulatory Minefield
Commissioner Peirce, who leads the SEC’s cryptocurrency task force, expressed her concerns that financial firms engaging in crypto activities are forced to operate in a regulatory environment that lacks transparency and consistency. She described the industry’s current state as one where SEC registrants must “hop from one poorly illuminated regulatory space to the next” while skillfully avoiding direct interaction with cryptocurrencies, which she metaphorically referred to as the "lava."
Speaking at the roundtable, Peirce highlighted the confusion surrounding the classification of various crypto assets as securities and the qualifications required for custodians of these assets. Many firms find themselves unsure of navigating complex issues such as custody violations related to “exercising staking or voting rights.”
“We need to turn on the lights and build some walkways over the lava pit,” Peirce urged, emphasizing the necessity for clearer guidelines that would allow firms to safely engage with crypto assets.
Barriers to Market Development
Peirce also pointed out the significant limitations faced by brokers and Alternative Trading Systems (ATS) that lack the ability to custody or manage crypto assets. She warned that these challenges impede the development of a robust trading market for cryptocurrencies, inhibiting innovation and investment in the sector.
In a related sentiment, SEC Commissioner Mark Uyeda echoed Peirce’s concerns during the event, asserting that as more SEC registrants begin working with crypto assets, it becomes essential to ensure access to qualified custodial options that adhere to existing legal and regulatory requirements. He proposed allowing advisers to utilize “state-chartered limited-purpose trust companies” with the proper authority to hold crypto assets.
A Call for Regulatory Clarity
The need for a clear regulatory framework was further underscored by the recently appointed SEC Chair, Paul Atkins. He expressed optimism about the potential benefits of blockchain technology, such as improved efficiency, enhanced transparency, and cost reductions. Atkins emphasized that among his objectives at the SEC would be establishing “clear regulatory rules of the road” for digital assets. He suggested that the previous leadership under Gary Gensler had contributed to market uncertainty and called for a collaborative approach with market participants and Congress to create a logical regulatory environment for cryptocurrencies.
Conclusion
As the cryptocurrency landscape continues to evolve, the emphasis on ensuring a sound regulatory framework is paramount. The insights from SEC officials, particularly Hester Peirce and Paul Atkins, highlight the need for cooperation between regulators and the crypto industry to facilitate clearer guidelines that would support market growth while ensuring investor protection.
Share this article:
