£1 Ketchup Tops Taste Test, Outshining Premium Brands and Gourmet Sauces

In an intriguing blind taste test conducted by Sky News, a £1 ketchup has emerged victorious, surpassing renowned brands and upscale sauces to claim the crown in this week’s edition of Our Verdict. This thorough taste assessment aimed to help consumers navigate the myriad of options on supermarket shelves, particularly as competition from budget supermarkets and online retailers increases.

Consumer Choices in Focus

The test serves as part of Sky News’ Money blog, a platform dedicated to consumer and personal finance insights. With the ongoing rise in product choices available to shoppers, knowing which items deliver optimal taste and value can be overwhelming. The blind taste test encompassed a total of 14 different ketchup varieties, including an array of supermarket own brands and high-end alternatives.

The Taste Test Breakdown

A panel of six expert taste testers meticulously sampled the ketchups, evaluating them for taste, texture, and overall balance. As expected, taste preferences varied significantly, especially among children who may refuse certain brands. However, when labels were removed and brands obscured, the results revealed some surprising outcomes.

Top 5 Ketchup Rankings

• First Place: M&S £1 Ketchup

  • Average Score: 7.6/10
  • Review: Touted for its thick yet smooth consistency, this sauce is rich in color and boasts a natural tomato flavor, complemented by a subtle kick. Its balanced profile makes it a family favorite for a variety of dishes.

• Second Place: Heinz £2.33 Ketchup

  • Average Score: 7.4/10
  • Review: A classic choice, this ketchup is known for its rich and smooth texture, pleasing a broad range of palates with its balanced flavor.

• Third Place: Wilkin and Sons £3.14 Ketchup

  • Average Score: 7.3/10
  • Review: As the leading "disruptor" brand in the test, its deep color and unique texture made it stand out. While it tastes distinctly homemade, it captured attention for its discreet tang.

• Fourth Place: Morrisons £1.99 Ketchup

  • Average Score: 6.5/10
  • Review: With a harmonious balance of sweet and smoky notes, it also received positive remarks regarding color and texture.

• Fifth Place: Asda £1 Ketchup

  • Average Score: 6.4/10
  • Review: While an everyday ketchup option, its paler color and thinner consistency detracted from its overall appeal.

Interestingly, the lowest-rated ketchup came from Aldi, priced at 89p. Despite being the cheapest, it managed to score the least on the taste scale, highlighting not all budget options guarantee quality.

Full Rankings and Insights

The taste test results have prompted discussions among consumers questioning the source and value of their condiment choices. The industry’s trends reflect a growing awareness as loyalty to traditional brands like Heinz is challenged by discerning shoppers seeking better value without sacrificing taste.

Other Ketchup Rankings Include:

• Sixth: Sainsbury’s (90p, 6.4 average score)
• Seventh: Lidl (£1.05, 6.0)
• Eighth: Stokes (£2.45, 5.8)
• Ninth: Waitrose (95p, 5.8)
• Tenth: Hellmann’s (£2, 5.7)
• Eleventh: Dr Wills (£3, 5.2)
• Joint Twelfth: Tesco (£1, 4.3)
• Joint Twelfth: Daddies (£1.50, 4.3)
• Last: Aldi (89p, 4.1)

Conclusion

The taste test results have not only revealed that consumers can often find exceptional quality in budget products, but they also encourage a rethinking of brand loyalty in favor of more cost-effective choices. With ketchups ranging widely in price and quality, this blind test underlines an essential mantra for consumers: sometimes, the best choice doesn’t have to come with a high price tag.

The results and further insights are available in the latest edition of the Money newsletter, ensuring subscribers stay ahead of the curve when it comes to smart consumer decisions.

Share this article: