The Phasing Out of Pennies: What It Means for Cash Transactions

In a significant move for the U.S. economy, the production of the penny coin is set to be phased out, a decision that could fundamentally alter the landscape of cash transactions, consumer behavior, and retail pricing strategies.

Background of the Decision

Earlier this year, President Trump directed the U.S. Treasury to halt the production of new pennies. Following this directive, the Treasury confirmed that the U.S. Mint would cease manufacturing the one-cent coins early next year once the existing stock of blank templates is depleted. The Mint announced that a final order for these pennies was placed this month, marking the beginning of the end for the long-standing coin.

It is worth noting that the Canadian government discontinued its penny in 2012, while countries like Australia and New Zealand stopped producing their lowest-denomination coins decades ago.

The Financial Implications

The decision to eliminate the penny comes as a response to rising production costs. The U.S. Treasury revealed that in the 2024 fiscal year, the cost of making a penny surged by 20%, from 1.3 cents a decade ago to approximately 3.69 cents per coin. In total, the Mint lost an estimated $85.3 million last year due to the production of nearly 3.2 billion pennies. Halting production is expected to save the government $56 million annually in reduced material costs.

In comparison, the cost of minting other coins is equally concerning. A nickel now costs about 13.78 cents to produce, while a dime costs 5.76 cents and a quarter costs around 14.68 cents.

Changes in Pricing Strategies

One of the most significant implications of removing the penny is the potential overhaul of retail pricing. The U.S. Treasury has advised that businesses will need to round prices up or down to the nearest 5 cents in transactions where exact change cannot be made due to the absence of pennies. This change is likely to affect the customary pricing strategy that frequently ends in 99 cents, which has been shown to influence consumer purchasing behavior.

While cash transactions may see this adjustment, digital payments will continue to reflect exact pricing, ensuring that the transition does not impact all payment forms equally.

Impact on Cash Usage

Despite the push towards digital and cashless payment systems, cash remains a prevalent method of payment, making up 16% of all transactions, according to the Federal Reserve’s 2024 Diary of Consumer Payment Choice. However, usage demographics reveal stark differences: consumers younger than 55 utilized cash for just 12% of their payments in 2023, while those 55 and older relied on cash for 22%.

Concerns are emerging over the fairness of rounding practices for lower-income and older Americans, who are more likely to depend on cash transactions. Jay Zagorsky, an author and Boston University professor, stressed the need for any proposed legislation to include requirements for fair rounding practices to safeguard these vulnerable populations.

The Broader Economic Context

An interesting facet of this transition is the factual revelation that billions of coins are sitting idle in households across the country. A 2022 Federal Reserve report estimated that about $14 billion in coins, or 60% of the circulating coin supply, is stored away in jars and piggy banks. Coinstar’s CEO, Kevin McColly, noted that this stagnation in the circulation of coins is creating unnecessary pressure on the need to mint new ones, despite having sufficient existing supply.

Conclusion

The decision to phase out the penny marks a pivotal moment in the evolution of cash transactions in the United States. As consumers and retailers prepare for these changes, the impacts on pricing, cash usage, and financial fairness remain critical topics for discussion. Retailers, legislators, and consumers alike will need to navigate this transition thoughtfully as the economy adjusts to life without pennies.

For those interested in the broader implications of changes in payment methods and financial policy, stay informed with updates from news sources like Smart Money Mindset.

Share this article: