Illegal Mining and Policy Gaps Stall Malaysia’s Crypto Growth Ecosystem

Overview of the Situation

The burgeoning cryptocurrency mining industry in Malaysia is grappling with significant challenges stemming from illegal mining activities and ambiguous regulatory frameworks. A recent report by the Access Blockchain Association of Malaysia provides alarming insights into the rampant electricity theft attributed to unauthorized miners, highlighting the potential the country has yet to fully realize in this lucrative sector.

Electricity Theft and Economic Losses

Electricity theft has escalated dramatically in Malaysia, particularly due to illegal Bitcoin mining operations. Between 2020 and September 2024, the state-owned energy provider Tenaga Nasional Berhad (TNB) reported losses amounting to 441.6 million Malaysian Ringgit (approximately $104.2 million) as a direct result of electricity theft. TNB noted that from 2018 to 2021, the total losses attributed to this illegal activity soared to an alarming 2.3 billion Ringgit.

The report emphasizes the inherent “latent demand” for cryptocurrency mining in Malaysia, explaining that formalizing these illegal activities could transform stolen energy into legitimate revenue streams for TNB and, by extension, generate much-needed taxable income for the government.

Potential for Revenue Generation

The Access Blockchain Association’s report suggests that if Malaysia can successfully onboard a fraction of the currently illegal miners to metered connections, the country could develop a multi-million-dollar revenue stream from its crypto mining operations. The idea of formalizing the sector has gained traction, as the document cites the benefits of creating a regulated and incentivized environment that would capitalize on unlicensed mining revenue.

Legal Operators and Concerns

While the Malaysian government has historically assumed a shortage of legal crypto miners, the report reveals that several medium and large-scale operators are already active but remain in the shadows. These legal miners are highly cautious, due to concerns about cyberattacks, physical theft, and the risk of sudden regulatory changes. The report identifies companies like Hatten Land, which are exploring above-ground mining infrastructure and forming partnerships to enhance their operations.

Malaysia’s Position in Global Mining

Boasting strong internet connectivity and abundant hydropower resources, Malaysia is strategically positioned to tap into the nearly $3 billion global cryptocurrency mining market. The country ranks between 7th and 8th worldwide in terms of hashrate, contributing approximately 2.5% to 3% of Bitcoin mining. However, despite these advantages, the lack of a specific regulatory framework for mining by the Securities Commission, which oversees crypto exchanges, poses substantial challenges for the industry.

Recommendations for Improvement

To address the issues stalling its crypto growth, the report offers several policy recommendations aimed at creating a more hospitable environment for legal cryptocurrency mining. Key proposals include:

• Establishing a mining-specific licensing framework.
• Introducing green tariff initiatives to encourage sustainable mining practices.
• Closing existing legal loopholes that facilitate electricity theft.
• Developing Shariah-compliant mining models to align with local financial principles.

Conclusion

The challenges facing Malaysia’s crypto mining sector are multi-faceted, ranging from illegal activities that drain resources to the need for a clearer regulatory environment. By addressing these issues, Malaysia has the potential not only to reclaim lost revenue but also to position itself as a significant player in the global cryptocurrency mining landscape.

Share this article: